The law around surrogacy could once again come under the spotlight this autumn after a public petition calling for reform secured more than 100,000 signatures, triggering a debate in Parliament on 7 September.
The petition asks for intended parents to be recognised as a child’s legal parents from birth, rather than having to apply for a parental order after the baby is born.
Why are people calling for change?
At the moment, the law in England and Wales says that the person who gives birth is automatically recognised as the child’s legal mother, regardless of any surrogacy agreement. If the surrogate is married or in a civil partnership, their spouse or civil partner may also be recognised as a legal parent.
This means that intended parents must apply to the family court for a parental order before they become their child’s legal parents. While this process exists to protect everyone involved, many families feel it no longer reflects the reality of modern surrogacy arrangements.
The petition was started by entrepreneur Adam Frisby after he and his husband welcomed their daughter through surrogacy in the United States. Although they were recognised as parents on their daughter’s US birth certificate, UK law still required them to go through the parental order process after returning home.
What happens next?
Because the petition passed the 100,000 signature threshold, it will now be debated by MPs in Parliament on 7 September.
A parliamentary debate does not automatically lead to a change in the law. However, it does provide an opportunity for MPs to discuss whether the current legal framework continues to meet the needs of children, surrogates and intended parents.
The Government has already acknowledged that the current system can create uncertainty for families. However, it has confirmed that it does not currently plan to introduce legislation to reform surrogacy law, although it says it will consider the issue when parliamentary time allows.
Reform has been discussed before
This is not the first time surrogacy law has been under review. In 2023, the Law Commission of England and Wales and the Scottish Law Commission published recommendations for a new legal framework. Among the proposals was a new pathway that, in certain regulated surrogacy arrangements, would allow intended parents to become their child’s legal parents from birth, removing the need for a parental order in those cases.
To date, those recommendations have not been implemented.
Why this matters
Surrogacy has become an increasingly important way for many people to build a family, including heterosexual couples experiencing infertility, same sex couples and single parents.
As family structures continue to evolve, there is ongoing discussion about whether the law should better reflect the intentions of everyone involved while continuing to provide appropriate safeguards for surrogates and children. The forthcoming parliamentary debate is likely to reignite that conversation and may influence the future direction of surrogacy law in England and Wales.
How we can help
Surrogacy law can be complex, particularly where arrangements involve international elements or questions about legal parenthood. Our specialist family lawyers can advise intended parents and families on the legal processes involved, including parental orders and the wider legal issues that can arise during a surrogacy journey.
We will be following the parliamentary debate with interest and will provide an update if there are any significant developments.
Need some advice? Get in touch today
"*" indicates required fields
The information submitted here is used and stored for the purpose of replying to the enquiry. For more information on how we process data please visit our Privacy Policy.