Divorce and Finance solicitor (and “parent” of a 3 year old Labrador) Stuart Smallman shares what happens to family pets when couples separate, why the law still treats them as property, and how disagreements over pets could be resolved during divorce.
After a long day in court, a settlement had finally been reached. Or so everyone thought. Counsel for one party quietly leaned over and said, “One more thing… my client wants his dog back.”
Cue the sinking feeling. Asking a client to part with a much-loved pet is never easy. But the solicitor dutifully checked in. Moments later, he returned with an answer no one expected: “My client agrees… but you do realise the dog is dead and buried at the bottom of the garden?”
Counsel did not realise.
It’s a funny story, but for most people dealing with divorce, the pet in question is very much alive. And that’s where the real conundrum begins.
Pets and divorce: where the law stands
More than half of UK households have a pet. Yet in the eyes of the Family Court, beloved companions are still treated as “property” under the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973. The same section that deals with record collections and televisions also deals with Labradors, cats and Alpacas.
According to a very quick web search 57% of the population are pet owners and I assume that most of them would not consider that pets are just a possession, they are much more than that. For many families, it feels completely out of step with modern life. Pets are part of the family, they shape routines, provide companionship and offer stability for children. But legally, they’re still considered chattels.
Disappointingly, but perhaps not surprisingly, the Family Court has so far failed to move with the times, unlike the courts in other countries who have started to shift.
Spain introduced legislation in 2022 requiring courts to consider the welfare needs of pets in divorce.
Portugal includes pet arrangements from the very start of proceedings.
In contrast, the UK is still catching up.
So what happens when couples disagree?
If a divorcing couple can’t agree who keeps the dog, the court can make an order transferring the pet to one party or even order it to be sold.
One judge, in a case remembered by many family lawyers, suggested that the parties sell the dog altogether – a comment that quickly pushed both sides back to negotiation, concerned about the fate of dear “Bertie” (not his real name).
If a Family Court has to make a decision on who should retain the pet dog for example, the cases of FI v DO (2024 ) EWFC 384 and RK v RK (2011) EWHC 3901 offers some guidance but no certainty to the dilemma. Attachment to the pet, the pet’s relationship with any children, and practical caring arrangements may all be considered, but nothing is guaranteed. Much depends on the judge and whether they see pets as family or simply another asset.
Are “pet-nups” the answer?
They can certainly help. A pet-nup (a written agreement setting out who the pet will live with and how costs will be shared) won’t bind the court absolutely, but it is often persuasive.
But above all, the best outcome almost always comes from discussion and agreement, ideally with support from mediation. It avoids conflict, legal costs and, importantly, any risk of a judge deciding something neither party wants.
Final thoughts on pets and divorce
Pets bring joy, comfort and connection at the very moment life feels most uncertain. Treating them as mere property doesn’t reflect how families feel about them. Until the law catches up, the most sensible and compassionate approach will always be reaching an agreement outside the courtroom.
Need some advice? Get in touch today
"*" indicates required fields
The information submitted here is used and stored for the purpose of replying to the enquiry. For more information on how we process data please visit our Privacy Policy.