This legal snapshot focuses on how the Court deals with balancing the risk of dividing high risk and low risk assets within divorce proceedings and which party carries the burden of the risk.
The recent ruling made by the Court of Appeal in Culligan -v Rosemin-Culligan [2026] EWCA Civ 948 has clarified the approach in which the Court can apply the ‘Wells sharing’ principle established by the case of Wells v- Wells [2002[ EWCA Civ 476.
What do we mean by ‘Wells Sharing’?
‘Wells sharing’ is an established approach taken by the Court in financial proceedings when considering how on divorce, to divide risky such as unquantifiable (such as a business) and non-risky assets like a property which has a value which can be certain. It means giving one persona a deferred share of the risky type asset so that whatever happens to it, that risk is shared, but generally it has been the case that one person carries far more of the risk than the other.
It has been seen as a principle of ‘last resort’ applied mainly to a small share of a divorce settlement. It could apply in cases which include high-risk assets that are difficult to value, such as illiquid assets, unpredictable future windfalls or private companies, as opposed to low-risk “liquid” assets, such as a family home or cash savings and investments. Under ‘Wells Sharing’ the court can share the risk between the parties and can order one party to have a share in the future of those assets of the other which cannot be clearly valued at the time of the divorce, for example when a company or shares owned by one is later sold or liquidated.
How did the Court approach it differently in the Culligan case?
In Culligan, at the first hearing before the High Court, it divided the overall assets between the husband and wife apparently equally, expressly to meet their equal needs. The husband however received a 70% share of the illiquid business assets, and the Wife 30%. The liquid assets were divided in the opposite way to achieve an overall balance, the balance of her share came mainly from the retention of the family home. This meant that the husband carried the higher risk. He appealed the Order, which he argued did not achieve a fair outcome.
The Court of Appeal overturned the High Court decision on the basis that the element of risk borne by the husband was unfair. In addition, the Court of Appeal found there was no rule that ‘Wells sharing’ was to be used as a last resort nor that it should be limited to a small proportion of the divorce settlement. The outcome was that the illiquid assets were to be divided equally between the husband and wife (not split 70/30) and the family home sold with the proceeds of sale divided equally.
The guidance from the Court of Appeal has therefore shifted the approach to sharing the risk equally between the parties.
What is the impact on cases where there are high risk illiquid assets?
Cases will always be decided on their own facts, but where needs are equal and illiquid assets are difficult to quantify at the time matters are decided by the Court, it is quite possible that the Court will spread the risk evenly between the parties, to achieve a fair and balanced outcome.
Need some advice? Get in touch today
"*" indicates required fields
The information submitted here is used and stored for the purpose of replying to the enquiry. For more information on how we process data please visit our Privacy Policy.