When a marriage or civil partnership ends, financial remedy proceedings determine how assets, income, and pensions are divided. Many of our clients, especially those who have been a victim of domestic abuse, often ask whether their former partner’s behaviour will influence the outcome. In England the answer is usually no except in rare and exceptional cases.
Does behaviour and conduct affect financial outcomes?
The court’s primary duty and overarching objective is to achieve a fair financial settlement. When considering a financial order, the Court will consider factors set out under s.25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973. It is not the role of the Court to punish wrongdoing or apportion blame by awarding the ‘innocent’ party a greater share of the available assets. Ordinary marital behaviour such as infidelity, arguments, or emotional withdrawal is not relevant to financial decisions.
When can conduct be considered?
Conduct is only taken into account where it would be inequitable to disregard it. This is a high legal threshold and typically applies where (OG v AG (Financial Remedies: Conduct) [2020] EWFV 52):
- There has been gross and obvious misconduct such as serious violence or criminal behaviour, where ignoring it would offend the court’s sense of justice.
- A party has deliberately and/or recklessly dissipated assets which would otherwise have formed part of the matrimonial pot, for example through gambling, hiding funds, or wantonly spending.
- Litigation misconduct, such as unreasonable behaviour in dealing with the financial proceedings.
- Failure to disclose full and frank disclosure where a party has perhaps failed to disclose the existence of assets available to them.
Even in these cases, the court will usually make a finding of conduct when the above behaviours are proved if there is a financial impact, not moral judgment. Case law on the issue of conduct has established that in majority of cases the party claiming conduct must demonstrate that there is a direct financial consequence. However, more recently Cusworth J remarked ‘there will always be some cases where it will be genuinely inequitable to disregard how one of the parties has behaved, and fair in all of the circumstances for that behaviour to be marked in the financial outcome in some way.’
A clear and practical approach
We will always be honest with you about whether a behaviour and conduct argument is likely to succeed and whether it is worth the time and cost involved. These issues are usually raised at the start of the process in the Form E, which is the financial disclosure document, but they can come up at any stage as matters progress.
It is worth knowing that weak conduct arguments can sometimes do more harm than good. They can increase costs, slow things down, and add unnecessary stress at an already difficult time.
Our focus is always on securing the best possible financial outcome for you in a way that feels sensible, proportionate, and in the best interests of your future.
Need some advice? Get in touch today
"*" indicates required fields
The information submitted here is used and stored for the purpose of replying to the enquiry. For more information on how we process data please visit our Privacy Policy.